Title
QTraxs free music downloads: Not yet - Machinist - Salon.com
Description
Salons Machinist, inside the tech innovations changing our lives. Read the latest technology news, blogs and articles from Salon tech writer Farhad Manjoo.
Keywords
Tech Blog, Tech News, Technology Articles, Salon, Machinist, Farhad Manjoo
Referer Text
QTraxs free music downloads: Not yet - Machinist - Salon.com
Google Page Rank
Page Content in text format
QTrax's free music downloads: Not yet - Machinist - Salon.com
body { word-wrap: break-word; }
.clearfix { height: 1%; }
#col1 #calendar_nav li { margin: 0; padding: 0; }
Machinist
Site presented by
Inside tech: Gizmos, people and big ideas
Blog
Archive
2008.01.28 • 16:15 EST
QTrax's free music downloads: Not yet
The Times of London headlined its announcement of a new legal music-download service quite dramatically: "From today, feel free to download another 25 million songs -- legally."
Well, not really, buster.
QTrax, the service being touted by the Times, put out word of its new plan at a music conference in Cannes this weekend. According to the company, the four major record labels had given the company their blessing to offer songs through a peer-to-peer download service that would be supported by advertising; you wouldn't pay a thing to download the songs.
But no sooner did QTrax go public than the record labels balked. All four -- Warner Music, Universal Music, EMI and Sony BMG -- say they have not signed deals with QTrax to offer such a plan. QTrax, which is supposed to be live now, doesn't work yet.
Allan Klepfisz, QTrax's CEO, tells CNet that there are only a few bureaucratic hurdles, and that the service will launch soon. "We plan to release music the way we said we were," he says.
Well, that'd be nice. QTrax's service sounds a bit iffy -- the tracks will contain copy protection, meaning they can't be used on iPods, which may be a deal-killer to many -- but of course, it'd be a sign of progress in the music business. It'd be fun to try. When one might get to do that isn't clear.
One more thing. The Times of London asked recording artist James Blunt what he made of such a service -- which promises to compensate artists when their music is downloaded -- and the dude went off the rails, suggesting that even legal downloading amounted to theft. "I'm amazed that we now accept that people steal music," he said. "I was taught not to steal sweets from a sweet shop. But I want to learn how this service works, given the condition the music industry is in."
I'd take time to explain the philosophical and legal differences between physical property and intellectual property -- that, you know, when you steal sweets in a shop you're depriving some other bloke of the sweets, but not so with copying music -- and I might point out that the sooner we begin to recognize such differences the sooner we'd get to saner, more prosperous and less anachronistic IP business models.
I would do all that, but haven't activists and legal experts and smart entrepreneurs been doing so for years now? Yup. And still there's no getting through.
― By Farhad Manjoo
Posted in: Copyright, Music
2 comments
Share
Email
Digg
Facebook
StumbleUpon
Reddit
P rint
QTrax's free music downloads: Not yet
About Machinist
Cyrus Farivar is a freelance technology journalist who regularly
reports for National Public Radio, PRI's The World, The Economist and
others. His forthcoming book is "The Internet of Elsewhere."
Tech News From The Wires
Astronauts step out for longest, hardest spacewalk
New space water recycling system has hiccups
NASA's space water recycling system has hiccups
Engineers sentenced to 1 year for espionage case
NASA scales back flagship Mars mission
Broadband makes tiny town an English-teaching hub
Microsoft exec: No job cuts here
Shuttle gives space station a mile-high boost
Engineers face jail in economic espionage case
Shuttle, astronauts prep for mid-mission reboost
Astronauts end spacewalk to repair gummed-up joint
Google empowers users to edit search results
Most Popular Salon Stories
Most Read
Active Letters
Most E-mailed
Get over it, Clinton haters
By Joe Conason
Is it OK to be liberal again, instead of progressive?
By Michael Lind
Tuning out the braindead megaphone
By David Sirota
First lady got back
By Erin Aubry Kaplan
I stole my lover's pot while he was sleeping
By Cary Tennis
The list of the governments that have persecuted journalists (218)
By Glenn Greenwald
Get over it, Clinton haters (206)
By Joe Conason
Is it OK to be liberal again, instead of progressive? (170)
By Michael Lind
Happy Thanksgiving, from Sarah Palin (89)
By Alex Koppelman
Vhat vomen vant (71)
By Kate Harding
Get over it, Clinton haters
By Joe Conason
Happy Thanksgiving, from Sarah Palin
By Alex Koppelman
First lady got back
By Erin Aubry Kaplan
Is it OK to be liberal again, instead of progressive?
By Michael Lind
Obama daughters going to Sidwell Friends
By Gabriel Winant
Recent Blog Posts
Fake text messages give false voting information
CNN debuts hologram technology to beam people in 3-D
Top 10 songs to rock your Obama victory party
Subscribe
Machinist RSS Feed
Login to Salon Premium
Currently in Salon
Get over it, Clinton haters
By Joe Conason
Tuning out the brain-dead megaphone
By David Sirota
NFL Week 12: Big-game picks
By King Kaufman
Posts by topic
Google
Copyright
XBox
Music
Facebook
Privacy
Yaho o
PS3
iPhone
Politics
Gadgets
Skype
MySpace
Voting
GMai l
NBC
Games
iPod
Wii
Microsoft
Search Engines
Voting Machines
Web Applications
iTunes
Apple
FCC
Video Games
YouTube
Netflix
Cell Phones
Nintendo
Sony
Hackers
Posts by date
←
November 2008SuMoTuWeThFrSa1234567891011121314151617181920212223 24252627282930
Salon Daily Newsletter
Get Salon in your mailbox!
Table Talk
What's on your iPhone?
Your favorite computer games for the holidays.
Salon
About Salon
Contact & Help
Corrections
Advertise in Salon
Salon Personals
Salon Jobs
Salon Mobile
Salon Newsletter
RSS Feeds
Salon Premium:
Premium log in
What is Salon Premium?
A & E
Books
Comics
Community: Table Talk & The WELL
Life
News & Politics
Opinion
Sports
Tech & Business
Letters
Investor Relations
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Copyright ©2008 Salon Media Group, Inc. Reproduction of material from any Salon pages without written permission is strictly prohibited. SALON® is registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office as a trademark of Salon Media Group Inc.
Url
http://machinist.salon.com/blog/2008/01/28/qtrax/
|
